India  

MOVIE REVIEW: Dumbo

One News Page Staff Monday, 1 April 2019
MOVIE REVIEW: Dumboby 👨‍💻 Graham Pierrepoint

DUMBO

IMDb

Dir: Tim Burton

Starring Colin Farrell, Michael Keaton, Danny DeVito, Eva Green, Alan Arkin, Nico Parker, Finley Hobbins, Roshan Seth

starstarstarstarstar    2 STARS (out of 5)

Disney is kicking off what looks set to be another groundbreaking year of box office smashes for the brand with another of their much-lauded ‘live action remakes’ of their animated classics. Following in the footsteps of Cinderella, The Jungle Book and Beauty and The Beast, Dumbo is a re-imagining of one of the studio’s oldest and perhaps most-revered pictures. Therefore, it was always going to be a little bit of challenge translating it to a whole new audience. While the original movie still has its charms for a modern viewer (racial stereotypes and alcohol references aside), the challenge here was making sure that a story about a cute, timid elephant that can fly can still capture the imaginations of children everywhere. While it succeeds in some regards, sadly, it flat out fails in others.

Re-framing the story from the perspective of Holt Farrier (Farrell) and his kids, who, following the passing of the family’s mother, find themselves readjusting to life on the road as part of a post-war circus troupe. Farrier has returned from the front having lost an arm, and also finds himself forced to cater to the elephants of the Medici Brothers’ Circus having been a big top cowboy his entire career. However, there’s one particular elephant he should be paying attention to – Dumbo, a new arrival who earns his name after a maiden performance that doesn’t go too well. However, ringmaster Max Medici (DeVito) sees dollar signs when it turns out the plucky pachyderm can fly – so too, apparently, does amusement park impresario V.A. Vandevere (Keaton), who has designs on the elephant all of his own.

Dumbo - Movie Review
Dumbo (Walt Disney Studios)

Let’s start with the good. Tim Burton is still a very talented director. He’s always been very at home with reaching into the past and adding his own charm to dark, gloomy scenarios. Dumbo is not a typical Burton film in that it’s not particular dark per se – though it is fairly gloomy in places. Here, however, Burton has captured the early-20th-century travelling circus aesthetic perfectly. He’s worked with DeVito and Keaton before (notably with Batman Returns), and the pair are perfectly cast in their roles.

Dumbo as a character and a creation is perfectly cute, and is probably the standout highlight of the movie – as he should be! The elephant has been well-realised for the live-action stage, and as such, I doubt many will have trouble falling in love with him. His story may be a little different here to his maiden voyage back in Disney’s early days, but he’s still as affable as ever. Thankfully, too, he still doesn’t speak a word.

However, it’s a great shame that there are so many problems with this movie. While DeVito and Keaton are having the time of their lives for the most part, the rest of the cast seem either to be going through the motions or to be completely perplexed by the material they’ve been given. DeVito even disappears around two-thirds of the way in, and when he does reappear, he seems a bit lost.

Arkin’s performance is more than a little stark here, while he is a talented actor and one who has earned his stripes, he really doesn’t fit in well with the material he has been given. The child actors, too – while I hate criticising young talent – really don’t seem ‘into it’. That seems to be the main problem with Dumbo – it feels like a dress rehearsal, and that Burton led with the first takes he got. Seasoned acting talent such as Roshan Seth are also completely wasted as background characters with very little in the way of dialogue. Green, at least, gives the material her all, and is also well-cast.

Dumbo - Official Trailer (Walt Disney Studios)

There are major problems with the story. It whittles along at an absolute break-neck pace, giving little moments to develop characters, relationships, or chances for the audience to get behind the plot. There are a lot of cliches in play here – which is fine for a family movie to an extent – but not only are they signposted with sledgehammer sensitivity, they make up the bulk of the plot. For a movie which seems to never stand still, not much in the way of originality ever gets accomplished. Admittedly, while it’s fair to say it’s a remake and a reimagining of the original animation, it really doesn’t stand on its own two feet too well, either.

My biggest gripe with Dumbo – which will resonate with audiences, too – is that the main character rather feels like a plot device, more than a character. We’re given far too much exposition and meaningless posturing offered by the human cast – with, again, little in the way of genuine development, intrigue or fun – and too little of the elephant himself. That’s a crying shame. Disney could have done more with Dumbo – it would have been great to have seen the elephant have more scenes to himself, without the relentless pacing and poor script hurrying him along. More moments with Dumbo flying, or in awe of some spectacle or other – would have been fantastic. The final scene of the movie, without spoiling anything major, is therefore my favourite.

All in all, however, Dumbo will be very disappointing to plenty of people. It really doesn’t feel like the best Burton could do with the character, and the script is far from its final draft. What’s more, some of the acting is just baffling. Did half of the cast simply not want to be there? There are too many jarring moments scattered throughout for me to give this any higher than a 2-star rating, which is a massive shame, as that’s one cute elephant.


13
shares
ShareTweetSavePostSend
 

💡 newsR Knowledge: Other News Mentions

Tim Burton Tim Burton American film director, producer, writer, and artist

Helena Bonham Carter thought Tim Burton was proposing when he offered her Alice role [Video]

Helena Bonham Carter thought Tim Burton was proposing when he offered her Alice role

Helena Bonham Carter thought her then-partner Tim Burton was about to propose when he offered her a role in his 2010 movie Alice in Wonderland.

Credit: Cover Video STUDIO    Duration: 00:52Published

Michael Keaton Michael Keaton American actor

NEWS OF THE WEEK: Michael Keaton confirmed to reprise Batman role for 'The Flash' movie [Video]

NEWS OF THE WEEK: Michael Keaton confirmed to reprise Batman role for 'The Flash' movie

It was reported earlier this year that Keaton, who portrayed the Caped Crusader in 1989's Batman and 1992's Batman Returns, and Ben Affleck, who played the superhero in 2016 and 17, would both be reprising the role for Andy Muschietti's standalone The Flash movie, which stars Ezra Miller.

Credit: Cover Video STUDIO    Duration: 00:57Published
Michael Keaton confirmed to reprise Batman role for 'The Flash' movie [Video]

Michael Keaton confirmed to reprise Batman role for 'The Flash' movie

It was reported earlier this year that Keaton, who portrayed the Caped Crusader in 1989's Batman and 1992's Batman Returns, and Ben Affleck, who played the superhero in 2016 and 17, would both be reprising the role for Andy Muschietti's standalone The Flash movie, which stars Ezra Miller.

Credit: Cover Video STUDIO    Duration: 00:57Published
NEWS OF THE WEEK: Michael Keaton not yet signed with 'The Flash' due to COVID concerns [Video]

NEWS OF THE WEEK: Michael Keaton not yet signed with 'The Flash' due to COVID concerns

Michael Keaton is currently non-committal about reprising Batman for The Flash as he wants to feel assured about filming during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Credit: Cover Video STUDIO    Duration: 00:44Published
Michael Keaton not yet signed with 'The Flash' due to COVID concerns [Video]

Michael Keaton not yet signed with 'The Flash' due to COVID concerns

Michael Keaton is currently non-committal about reprising Batman for The Flash as he wants to feel assured about filming during the COVID-19 pandemic.

Credit: Cover Video STUDIO    Duration: 00:44Published

The Walt Disney Company The Walt Disney Company American mass media corporation

Disney, Six Flags' Roller Coaster COVID Restrictions, Cautious or Ridiculous

California's thankfully seeing a major dip in COVID cases and deaths, but roller coaster thrill-seekers are still required to follow serious safety guidelines..
TMZ.com
Ewan McGregor Confirms Lightsaber Fight Claim from Noel Gallagher | THR News [Video]

Ewan McGregor Confirms Lightsaber Fight Claim from Noel Gallagher | THR News

When Ewan McGregor stopped by 'Jimmy Kimmel Live!' on Monday, the actor shared some behind-the-scenes details from working on his highly-anticipated Obi-Wan Kenobi series for Disney+, as well as confirmed an old lightsaber fight claim from Noel Gallagher.

Credit: The Hollywood Reporter    Duration: 01:27Published
Mookie Betts & Andrew McCutchen are animated for Disney series [Video]

Mookie Betts & Andrew McCutchen are animated for Disney series

The Dodgers right fielder and Phillies center fielder are voicing characters for the animated kids series 'Puppy Dog Pals'.

Credit: Cover Video STUDIO    Duration: 00:45Published
Anthony Mackie Recalls Serendipitous Captain America Encounter | THR News [Video]

Anthony Mackie Recalls Serendipitous Captain America Encounter | THR News

Anthony Mackie had a run-in with a Captain America many years ago that foretold the actor would become the first Black man to play the superhero. Mackie took over the Cap mantle during the recent conclusion of 'Falcon and The Winter Soldier' on Disney+.

Credit: The Hollywood Reporter    Duration: 01:42Published
Sisters who put on a Frozen show for a sad birthday girl in lockdown launch a business performing as Disney princesses Elsa and  [Video]

Sisters who put on a Frozen show for a sad birthday girl in lockdown launch a business performing as Disney princesses Elsa and

Good Samaritan sisters who brought a local girl's fourth birthday to life by performing as princesses from Disney's Frozen have turned their lockdown kindness into a thriving business - charging between £10 and £250 a show.Both "resting" from the theatre because of Covid-19, acting duo Eloise and Natalya Smith say their story is like "a real-life fairy-tale" - having thought the show for their next-door neighbour's girl in Camberley, Surrey, last May would be a one-off.

Credit: PA - Press Association STUDIO    Duration: 01:51Published

Cinderella (2015 Disney film) Cinderella (2015 Disney film) 2015 film directed by Kenneth Branagh

Amazon bosses pick up Camila Cabello's 'Cinderella' [Video]

Amazon bosses pick up Camila Cabello's 'Cinderella'

Amazon Prime bosses are closing a deal to acquire worldwide rights to Camila Cabello's movie debut as 'Cinderella.'

Credit: Cover Video STUDIO    Duration: 00:56Published

You Might Like

•More original news reports from newsR