> >


One News Page Staff Tuesday, 2 May 2017
MOVIE REVIEW: The Promiseby



Dir: Terry George

Starring Oscar Isaac, Christian Bale, Charlotte Le Bon, Daniel Gimenez Cacho, Shohreh Aghdashloo, Andrew Tarbet, Angela Sarafyan, Jean Reno, Marwan Kenzari, Tom Hollander

starstarstarstarstar    2.5 STARS (out of 5)

War films seem to have sprung up a little lately – while the UK’s own Their Finest dealt with the theme of propaganda during a time of great unease on British soil, Terry George’s latest film attempts to put forward a historical event which still continues to go denied by many. Set during the fall of the Ottoman Empire in the early 20th century, George makes a clear attempt to educate a wider audience about the rounding-up and genocide of Armenian people in what is now regarded as modern-day Turkey. The film – The Promise – was even subject to some controversy on its initial premiere, as it appeared to be subject to a deluge of one-star reviews on IMDb. Was the influx politically motivated? Regardless of where you stand, it can hardly be said that such a paltry rating is applicable here.

The Promise - Review

Focusing on three people caught up in the growing unrest in 1914 and 1915, Oscar Isaac portrays an Armenian man keen to study medicine and to help improve the standard of medical care in Southern Turkey. On his travels, he meets Ana (Charlotte Le Bon), with whom he immediately clicks – however, she has a boorish American beau (Christian Bale) – igniting a to-and-fro love triangle that is to unfold upon a backdrop of war and atrocity. Will love survive the conflict – and can the men put their differences aside to help the Armenian people of Turkey?

George is perhaps most famous for bringing the award-winning Hotel Rwanda to cinemas, and it is clear that he is aiming to cultivate similar gravitas with an idea and a script that is partly written to help educate a wider populace about exactly what went on in Turkey during 1914 and 1915. Rather than focus entirely on the atrocities themselves, however, The Promise throws a rather cinematic love triangle into the mix, likely to help add some humanity to proceedings and to help ease the moviegoing public into the themes covered. For the most part, this certainly works – Oscar Isaac once again proves he is marvellously versatile and dependable in a lead role, Charlotte Le Bon proves to be a star on the rise, and Christian Bale – love him or hate him – is always worth watching.

The Promise - Official Trailer (Open Road Films)

What The Promise does well is, certainly, deliver its central point – of showcasing exactly what went on during the Armenian genocide to the extent where, somewhat effectively, we genuinely care about what happens next. While it does perhaps miss out on that hallowed grandiose war ‘epic’ status that it is perhaps trying to chase down, it never relents on being interesting – it is perhaps telling therefore that this side of the picture, at the very least, should have been given more of a focus. While George has clearly attempted to ease the story in with a central premise and story between three characters we could come to follow and admire – it’s the romantic aspect that never quite hits the heights it hopes to.

While The Promise is finely shot and has a very clear idea in mind, the central love triangle – despite the cast all working well – is far too derivative of similar movies we have seen hundreds of times over. The romance and the building tension would, on paper, be all the more predictable – and it is genuinely saccharine and rather unbearable at its worst. Certainly, it is a unique experience to behold a movie so focused on one hand in bringing a tale of genuine atrocity to audiences while using the other to layer on a romantic overlay that never really goes anywhere we’d like it to. Thousands of other movies before The Promise have earned their status from balancing genuinely intriguing character stories alongside captivating backdrops – whether they be war, devastation, or something else entirely – it has become something of the formula that Titanic laid down as groundwork twenty years ago. Sadly, while the paper-light nature of the central plot doesn’t let the side down entirely, it certainly doesn’t help the movie hit the heights it ought to.

On paper, The Promise could have been incredible – but without more of a slant towards the epic and without a core premise that stands up to the grandiosity of the backdrop and history in play, we are left with a movie which, while interesting and important, fails to stand up as a piece of truly transformative and intriguing film. For those interested in this devastating piece of history, it cannot be recommended enough – but beyond the social and historical merits, The Promise stands to be sadly forgotten due to far more effective contemporaries. With a solid cast, direction and more besides, it’s a film that deserves watching – but it could have been so much more.

Share on
Share on
Post on 
Share by

You Might Like

Recent related news

Mahanati movie review and rating by audience: Live updates

By Shekhar H Hooli Mahanati movie review live updates: Director Nag Aswin’s Telugu movie starring Keerthy Suresh, Dulquer Salmaan, Samantha Akkineni and Vijay...
Filmy Friday - EntertainmentAlso reported by •DNAZee NewsFirstpost

102 Not Out LIVE movie review: Check out the first day, first show verdict of Amitabh Bachchan and Rishi Kapoor’s film

102 Not Out movie review out! The film starring Amitabh Bachchan and Rishi Kapoor has finally hit the screens today and before you book your tickets, take a look...
Bollywood Life - IndiaAlso reported by •Zee News

Manhunt movie review: John Woo's Netflix offering is a homage to '90s action films stuck in the bygone era

In Manhunt, what hurt my expectations the most was the action - the one thing that John Woo is known for. The fight choreography is too '90s for my taste.
Firstpost - EntertainmentAlso reported by •Bollywood Life

Naa Peru Surya movie review: Allu Arjun is a show-stealer in this unusual tale about patriotism, failed relationships and love

Check out the full review of Allu Arjun's Naa Peru Surya
Bollywood Life - IndiaAlso reported by •Firstpost

Iruttu Araiyil Murattu Kuththu movie review: Why have a story when you can mix horror, comedy and call it a day?

Iruttu Araiyil Murattu Kuththu (IAMK) is an adult horror comedy from the hit team of Gautham Karthik and director Santhosh P Jayakumar of Hara Hara Mahadevaki...
Firstpost - Entertainment

Guptodhoner Sandhane movie review: Dhrubo Banerjee takes us on a joyride of a treasure hunt

Drawing heavily from Satyajit Ray's Feluda stories and the adventures of Indiana Jones, Dhrubo Banerjee's new treasure hunt adventure flick has all the...
Firstpost - Entertainment

Tweets about this


Sᴀʟᴍᴀɴɪᴀᴄ🎭ᴷᴷᴿ 55. Watched The Promise (2016)Drama/War My Review: This is really good movie. And very well balanced with action,… 12 hours ago


Sage I promise you that's a direct quote from a real review of this movie. 23 hours ago


MaryAnn Johanson #BlockersMovie opens in North America today. I promise you, it's better than you're expecting. 2 days ago


Generic Brand Laundry Pod YouTube keeps suggesting such***to me. I promise that I have never, and will never watch a movie review by Armor… 2 days ago


Tim Nagle RT @MoviesForReel: Stop! We've got a review for #AQuitePlace online now! No spoilers, we promise.… 3 days ago


ForReel Stop! We've got a review for #AQuitePlace online now! No spoilers, we promise. 3 days ago


Bette Brunswick The Shrew View Did you see the movie Lady Bird? Read my blog for a review. I promise that it's not a spoiler ;-)… 4 days ago


🌸Ally🌸 @BenCarlson25 Actually, if you promise not to let Ethan do a mother movie review eppie I’ll sponsor you 5 days ago

Other recent news in Entertainment

MET GALA 2018 after-party: Priyanka Chopra sizzles while Deepika Padukone disappoints againCANNES FILM FESTIVAL 2018: Netflix, Orson Welles, Nandita Das' Manto and #MeToo
Bardem and Cruz walk the red carpet to open CANNES Film FestivalVideos: Karan Johar, Anil Kapoor, Arjun Kapoor set the dance floor on fire at Sonam Kapoor-ANAND AHUJA's reception
Sonam Kapoor-Anand Ahuja wedding: ARJUN KAPOOR, Varun Dhawan groove to Badshah's tracks at starry sangeetVenom is not part of Marvel Cinematic Universe, confirms Avengers: INFINITY WAR director Joe Russo

Recent related videos

News video: MoviePass Rival Sinemia Ups The Ante

▶ MoviePass Rival Sinemia Ups The Ante 00:38

MoviePass competitor Sinemia has introduced a new subscription model for its customers. The company was originally a success in the U.K., Canada, Turkey, and Australia, but only in California in the..
Source: Wochit -

News video: New Working Title Revealed For 'John Wick 3'

▶ New Working Title Revealed For 'John Wick 3' 00:40

‘John Wick: Chapter 3' has a new working title that seems to promise a coming war. According to Omega Underground, the film is now going by the code name “Parabellum.” Parabellum is Latin for..
Source: Wochit -

News video: 'Overboard' gets in deep, can't bail itself out (MOVIE REVIEW)

▶ 'Overboard' gets in deep, can't bail itself out (MOVIE REVIEW) 02:13

A remake of the fondly remembered 1987 Goldie Hawn-Kurt Russell caper comedy, the new "Overboard" can't come close to the screwball charm and charisma of the original.
Source: Rumble -

News video: “Omerta” PUBLIC REVIEW | Rajkummar Rao as British Terrorist

▶ “Omerta” PUBLIC REVIEW | Rajkummar Rao as British Terrorist 02:25

Actor Rajkummar Rao starrer “Omerta”, which is a biographical crime drama and tells the story of Ahmed Omar Saeed Sheikh, has finally hit the theaters today. Omerta” was screened in..
Source: IANS Bollywood Videos -

News video: REVIEW | “102 Not Out” PUBLIC Flatters Rishi & Big B’s FUN

▶ REVIEW | “102 Not Out” PUBLIC Flatters Rishi & Big B’s FUN 01:34

After receiving positive response from Bollywood, "102 Not Out", which portrays the relationship between a 102-year-old father, essayed by Big B, and his 75-year-old son, played by Rishi, has..
Source: IANS Bollywood Videos -

News video: 'Tully' review by Justin Chang

▶ 'Tully' review by Justin Chang 02:15

“Tully” is one of the more viscerally accurate, in-your-face portraits of parenthood, and specifically motherhood, that I’ve seen in a movie lately.
Source: NYDN tronc -

News video: Avengers: Infinity War Review

▶ Avengers: Infinity War Review 03:52

none, Review, Marvel's The Avengers: Infinity War, movie, Super-Hero, Action, Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, Marvel Studios
Source: IGN -

News video: Why Is Martin Scorsese Concerned For Health Of Movie Business?

▶ Why Is Martin Scorsese Concerned For Health Of Movie Business? 00:33

Martin Scorsese has hit out at review aggregator websites, like Rotten Tomatoes. To Scorsese, the sites devalue cinema. It can all be summed up in the word that's being used now: content. You've..
Source: Wochit -

•More original news reports from newsR
Environmentally friendly: newsR is hosted on servers powered solely by renewable energy
© 2018 newsR / One News Page Ltd. All Rights Reserved.  |  About us  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms & Conditions  |  Privacy Policy  |  Content Accreditation
 RSS  |  News for my Website  |  Free news search widget  |  Help  |  Contact us  |  DMCA / Content Removal
How are we doing? Send us your feedback  |   LIKE us on Facebook   FOLLOW us on Twitter