India  
NewsR.in
> >

MOVIE REVIEW: Downsizing

One News Page Staff Thursday, 22 February 2018
MOVIE REVIEW: Downsizingby

DOWNSIZING

IMDb

Dir: Alexander Payne

Starring Matt Damon, Christoph Waltz, Hong Chau, Kristen Wiig, Udo Kier

starstarstarstarstar    0.5 STARS (out of 5)

Downsizing has been out in cinemas for some time now, and while I have only had the chance to watch and review the movie in recent times, I genuinely feel it is worth doing for a number of reasons. Last week, I reviewed the third instalment in the critically lambasted Fifty Shades of Grey series – a trio of movies which has received bottom-of-the-barrel scores across the board – and yet, even now, I can safely say that I was less disappointed having seen another hour and a half of Anastasia Steele and Christian Grey than I was having sat through Downsizing. This is perhaps not only a prime contender for my least favourite movie of the year (we’re only in February), but perhaps one of my least favourite movies of all time. It is a picture that is so polarising, it teeters on that rare 50-51% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes – and my reasons for so disliking this movie so intensely deride largely from the fact that it is such a colossal, unmitigated waste of a premise, it genuinely beggars belief. What actually happened here?

For the first time in a long time, perhaps since I started these reviews, here is a spoiler warning – I’m going to need to discuss why this movie fails to work on so many levels by giving away a fair chunk of what transpires.

Downsizing - Movie Review
Downsizing (Paramount Pictures)

The concept here is pure sci-fi – brilliant sci-fi – as society starts deciding to shrink themselves to be able to boost their income and to effectively live easier lives –following pioneering trials. It effectively means that you’d shrink yourself to a tiny size forever to be able to convert your meagre savings into millions of dollars – and, for the most part, everything seems cushy. Matt Damon is Paul Safranek, who, with wife Audrey (Kristen Wiig), decides to go for the downsizing route – only for Audrey to back out mid-process, and after Paul has already been shrunk. From here, Paul descends into a mid-life crisis of sorts – and it’s right about here that things really start to go downhill.

This movie could have been brilliant. It could have been a comedy – the trailers certainly made it seem that it was – it could quite easily have been a horror. The first half an hour is great – the set-up is amazing – you are genuinely looking forward to seeing what happens in the smaller community, how they survive, what problems they face, whether there’s any sinister secrets hiding beneath the surface of downsizing as a concept. It could have gone in a million different directions. Instead, bizarrely, once Kristen Wiig (disappointingly only on screen for about fifteen minutes in total) is out of the picture – literally – the script weirdly descends into a muddling, moping mess.

It shows us what happens to Paul – he has a wild night with a neighbour, he finds someone he thinks he can help treat (he’s an occupational therapist), and we find that there are slums full of impoverished downsizers – and this is where the political message creeps in. It is a hugely important message – we should all be looking after each other within our means – but it is so weirdly shoehorned in and so aggressively so that the movie changes shape and tack completely. We are introduced to a Vietnamese rebel played by Hong Chau – who, for some reason, is depicted in such a bizarrely insensitive and uncomfortable way that it’s almost painful to behold. The script is largely to blame – and I’m only scratching the surface.

The movie later decides to maintain this new character as pivotal to Paul’s life, as he continues to try and find his purpose in the small community – only for a third act to completely derail the plot yet again, with several characters learning that global warming is set to destroy the world ‘soon’. This means that we have moved from an interesting sci-if premise with a horror/comedy slant about shrinking to save money, into a dark, depressing and political study that doesn’t make much sense within the world of the film (though I guess black market downsizing exists?) – only for it to swerve again into an allegory about environmental disaster. These are all good things to be caring about – let me make this abundantly clear – but this film is written and carried out in such a haphazard and blindly stumbling fashion that it is completely and utterly underwhelming on almost every level. I’ll ask again – what happened here?

The trailers have come under fire for, according to some people, depicting events in a manner that transpire differently to how they are carried out. This isn’t anything new, but it’s still part of the bigger problem. A huge problem – and this is a big one –is that, from the second act onwards, we might as well not be in the small world anymore. There are a couple of nods here and there, but that part of the film – the one with promise and the one most people signed up to watch – was clearly forgotten about a long time ago. I’m all for movies putting across important messages – and the ones here are very relevant indeed – but to completely throw your main concept away in favour of hammering home two almost completely unrelated acts? I don’t think I’ve been as disappointed in a movie since watching The Circle.

Downsizing - Official Trailer (Paramount Pictures)

Downsizing, had it retained its focus on the main premise and had it gone in a direction which may even have been considered safe, it would have actually still been fairly enjoyable – let’s see a sinister plot get unearthed, or see what happens to small people in our larger world, or let’s even see what other small communities are like – instead, we have baffling swerves and misdirections which not only come across as desperately non-sensical, but also deeply unsatisfying. There have been critical appraisals of this movie – perhaps for the messages that it is putting across –but the way in which it does this, especially in light of destroying a brilliantly serviceable premise – is nothing short of infuriating.

Downsizing is out on DVD and Blu-Ray soon – I’d suggest seeing if any deleted scenes suggest what might have been – but I’d sooner recommend you rent or stream Honey I Shrunk The Kids instead. An utterly unmitigated waste of a premise, and one which remains bitterly disappointing.


21
shares
Share on
Facebook
Share on
Twitter
Post on 
Reddit
Share by
Email
 

You Might Like


Tweets about this

MWTMPodcast

Movies With The Mrs. RT @casualcinecast: Check out our review of the surprisingly thoughtful film, #Tully, written by #DiabloCody, Directed by #JasonReitman. St… 3 days ago

casualcinecast

Casual Cinecast Check out our review of the surprisingly thoughtful film, #Tully, written by #DiabloCody, Directed by #JasonReitman… https://t.co/49UYZZNWdG 5 days ago

_firstbooklove

Michelle(Firstbooklove) Movie Review: Downsizing (2017) (3.5 Stars) https://t.co/O4bJjYyc7m https://t.co/PZd7iLSFCE 1 week ago


Other recent news in Entertainment

Race 3 BOX OFFICE collection: Salman Khan-starrer records 2018's biggest opening, earns Rs 29 cr on Day 1Salman Khan starrer Race 3 eclipses Veere Di Wedding and Parmanu's box OFFICE collections
Eid ul-Fitr 2018: Varun Dhawan, Shraddha Kapoor, Jacqueline Fernandez wish their fans EID MUBARAK in styleWATCH: An infuriated ANUSHKA SHARMA rolls down her car's window and blasts commuter for throwing plastic on the road
Amitabh Bachchan starts shooting for Sujoy Ghosh's Badla co-starring Taapsee Pannu in GLASGOWSHIRISH KUNDER took a hilarious dig at LG of Delhi, LG electronics took it too seriously

Recent related videos

News video: 'The Incredibles 2' gets the family back together with vigor (MOVIE REVIEW)

▶ 'The Incredibles 2' gets the family back together with vigor (MOVIE REVIEW) 02:23

"The Incredibles" came out so long ago that some people who saw it as kids will now be taking their own children to see the sequel. In most ways, the Pixar follow-up was well worth..
Source: Rumble -

News video: Race 3 Public Review | Has Salman overshadowed Saif

▶ Race 3 Public Review | Has Salman overshadowed Saif 02:06

After much anticipation 'Race 3' has finally made it to the theaters today and looks like many have revolted against it liking the previous parts featuring Saif Ali Khan as the main actor. So overall ,..
Source: IANS INDIA -

News video: Ryan Jay Reviews Incredibles 2

▶ Ryan Jay Reviews Incredibles 2 04:21

Thinking about seeing a movie this weekend, but are afraid it won't be worth your time or money? Well, we have you covered! Ryan Jay, a nationally syndicated radio film critic and entertainment guru,..
Source: TODAY’S TMJ4 -

News video: Incredibles 2 vs. The Incredibles: Worth the Wait? - Mojo @ the Movies

▶ Incredibles 2 vs. The Incredibles: Worth the Wait? - Mojo @ the Movies 09:44

Is Incredibles 2 going to be good? There have been a lot of Pixar sequels recently; from Toy Story 2 (and 3, and 4...) to Finding Dory to Cars 2, there have been some great Pixar sequels, and some bad..
Source: WatchMojo - Affiliate -

News video: Salman Khan's selfie time with kids | Race 3 party

▶ Salman Khan's selfie time with kids | Race 3 party 01:03

Prior to the release of the action-thriller film 'Race 3', the team were seen partying as hosted by Producer Ramesh Taurani. Well, of course the entire cast of 'Race 3' was present..
Source: IANS Bollywood Videos -

News video: 'Incredibles 2' review by Kenneth Turan

▶ 'Incredibles 2' review by Kenneth Turan 01:56

The Incredibles are back 14 years later in "Incredibles 2," except this time Elastigirl takes the lead, while Mr. Incredible is home with the kids.
Source: NYDN tronc -

News video: Brie Larson Calls For More Diversity Among Film Critics

▶ Brie Larson Calls For More Diversity Among Film Critics 00:33

The SF Gate is reporting that actress Brie Larson wants more diversity. Specifically, she's extending the call for more diversity in Hollywood to the journalists who cover the industry. On Wednesday,..
Source: Wochit -

News video: Arshi Khan and RJ Preetam Support RACE 3 | Latest Bollywood News | Race 3 Review

▶ Arshi Khan and RJ Preetam Support RACE 3 | Latest Bollywood News | Race 3 Review 00:35

Arshi Khan and RJ Preetam Support RACE 3 | Latest Bollywood News | Race 3 Review.
Source: Bollywood Gossip -

•More original news reports from newsR
Environmentally friendly: newsR is hosted on servers powered solely by renewable energy
© 2018 newsR / One News Page Ltd. All Rights Reserved.  |  About us  |  Disclaimer  |  Terms & Conditions  |  Content Accreditation
 RSS  |  News for my Website  |  Free news search widget  |  Help  |  Contact us  |  DMCA / Content Removal  |  Privacy & Data Protection Policy
How are we doing? Send us your feedback  |   LIKE us on Facebook   FOLLOW us on Twitter