India  

Alabama’s Supreme Court Rules Embryos Are ‘Extrauterine Children’

Video Credit: Wibbitz Top Stories - Duration: 01:31s - Published
Alabama’s Supreme Court Rules Embryos Are ‘Extrauterine Children’

Alabama’s Supreme Court Rules Embryos Are ‘Extrauterine Children’

Alabama’s Supreme Court Rules , Embryos Are ‘Extrauterine Children’.

The first-of-its-kind ruling was made on Feb.

16.

It "could have widespread implications" for in vitro fertilization (IVF) practices, 'The Guardian' reports.

.

According to Alabama Dr. Mamie McLean, patients are wondering if they can still safely become parents with IVF.

They’re worried about what to do with their frozen embryos.

They want to be the ones who make the decisions on how best to utilize their embryos – not the Supreme Court, Dr. Mamie McLean, via 'The Guardian'.

Frankly, because of the lack of guidance, we don’t know exactly how this translates to our care, Dr. Mamie McLean, via 'The Guardian'.

Since each embryo is now considered a person in Alabama, doctors may have issues freezing, thawing, transferring or testing them, 'The Guardian' reports.

.

It's also not clear if embryos, which are often produced in excess to provide optimal chances for pregnancy, can ever be disposed of if no longer needed.

Sean Tipton, chief advocacy and policy officer for the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, called the decision a "nonsensical ruling with devastating consequences.".

The court, of course, didn’t deign to deal with the real-world implications of their decision, but they are profound, Sean Tipton, chief advocacy and policy officer for the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, via 'The Guardian'.

If you’re a physician or an embryologist working in that clinic, you now stand ready to be charged with manslaughter or threatened with a wrongful death suit because one of the embryos didn’t happen to survive the freeze-thaw process, Sean Tipton, chief advocacy and policy officer for the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, via 'The Guardian'.

Providers may also be forced to transfer multiple embryos to patients, which could result in twins, triplets or more, endangering a patient's health.


You Might Like


💡 newsR Knowledge: Other News Mentions

Alabama Alabama U.S. state

These Are the Women’s NCAA Final Four Teams [Video]

These Are the Women’s NCAA Final Four Teams

These Are the Women’s , NCAA Final Four Teams. On April 1, Caitlin Clark and the Iowa Hawkeyes defeated Angel Reese and the LSU Tigers 94-87, NPR reports. . On April 1, Caitlin Clark and the Iowa Hawkeyes defeated Angel Reese and the LSU Tigers 94-87, NPR reports. . Also on April 1, the University of Connecticut beat the University of Southern California 80-73. Also on April 1, the University of Connecticut beat the University of Southern California 80-73. Both teams will join North Carolina State and South Carolina in the Final Four. Both teams will join North Carolina State and South Carolina in the Final Four. On April 5, Iowa will go up against UConn, and North Carolina State will face off against South Carolina. On April 5, Iowa will go up against UConn, and North Carolina State will face off against South Carolina. On April 5, Iowa will go up against UConn, and North Carolina State will face off against South Carolina. On April 5, Iowa will go up against UConn, and North Carolina State will face off against South Carolina. The back-to-back games will kick off at 7 p.m. ET on ESPN. Women's college basketball has garnered record TV ratings this year as popular players such as Caitlin Clark, Angel Reese, . Women's college basketball has garnered record TV ratings this year as popular players such as Caitlin Clark, Angel Reese, . JuJu Watkins and Paige Bueckers have become household names, NPR reports. . JuJu Watkins and Paige Bueckers have become household names, NPR reports. . The men's teams at UConn and NC State have also made it to the Final Four. The men's teams at UConn and NC State have also made it to the Final Four. The men's Final Four games will kick off on April 6 when Purdue battles NC State, and UConn goes up against Alabama. The men's Final Four games will kick off on April 6 when Purdue battles NC State, and UConn goes up against Alabama. The men's Final Four games will kick off on April 6 when Purdue battles NC State, and UConn goes up against Alabama. The men's Final Four games will kick off on April 6 when Purdue battles NC State, and UConn goes up against Alabama. The women's title game will take place on April 7 at 3 p.m. ET on ABC. The men's title game will happen on April 8

Credit: Wibbitz Top Stories    Duration: 01:31Published
Alabama Governor Signs IVF Protection Bill [Video]

Alabama Governor Signs IVF Protection Bill

Alabama Governor Signs, IVF Protection Bill . On March 6, Alabama Governor Kay Ivey signed legislation aimed at protecting in vitro fertilization patients and providers from legal liability. CNN reports that some clinics are ready to lift a hold on certain IVF services as early as this week. . The Alabama bill comes after an unprecedented state Supreme Court ruling cast the future of IVF care into doubt. The Supreme Court case reportedly stemmed from the accidental destruction of frozen embryos at a fertility clinic. The state Supreme Court ruled that frozen embryos are human beings, meaning that those who destroy them could be held liable for wrongful death. The latest bill signed into law by the governor aims to provide both civil and criminal immunity to providers and patients in the case of embryos being damaged or destroyed. However, the fertility clinics say that the new law doesn't address the core issue and fails to provide the legal protection necessary to resume care. The law does not nullify the Supreme Court’s analysis that says the law ought to treat embryos just like people, Katherine Kraschel, assistant professor at Northeastern University School of Law, via CNN. CNN reports that experts have warned that the latest bill could also insulate providers from standard medical malpractice claims. The governor stressed that the new law is meant to be a "short-term measure" and reassured that "there will be more work to come" on ensuring IVF protections.

Credit: Wibbitz Top Stories    Duration: 01:31Published
Senate Democrats Will Attempt to Pass Legislation Protecting IVF [Video]

Senate Democrats Will Attempt to Pass Legislation Protecting IVF

Senate Democrats Will Attempt , to Pass Legislation Protecting IVF. On Feb. 27, Democratic Senator Tammy Duckworth said that she will seek an immediate vote on Feb. 28 to pass her Access to Family Building Act, Reuters reports. . The push comes after Alabama ruled that embryos are essentially children, causing widespread implications for patients and doctors. . If you truly care about the sanctity of families, and you’re genuinely actually honestly interested in protecting IVF, then you need to show it by not blocking this bill on the floor tomorrow. It’s that simple, Sen. Tammy Duckworth, via statement. Duckworth, an Iraq War veteran, and her husband turned to IVF after not being able to conceive for 10 years. They currently have two children. . I have five embryos that were created (using IVF); three that were deemed to be nonviable, would not survive, Sen. Tammy Duckworth, via statement. Under "personhood laws" such as those enacted in Alabama, Duckworth said, "I could be convicted of manslaughter or murder for discarding these three eggs that were nonviable.". Under "personhood laws" such as those enacted in Alabama, Duckworth said, "I could be convicted of manslaughter or murder for discarding these three eggs that were nonviable.". While many Republicans have objected to Alabama's ruling, they are expected to block Duckworth's bill despite indicating otherwise, Reuters reports. . Duckworth said that if Republicans end up objecting to the bill, she'd "love" to have those individuals named on the record. . I expect them to, if they live up to the words that they’re saying, to not block it. But we’ll see tomorrow when the rubber hits the road, Sen. Tammy Duckworth, via statement

Credit: Wibbitz Top Stories    Duration: 01:31Published
Alabama lawmakers look for IVF solution as patients remain in limbo [Video]

Alabama lawmakers look for IVF solution as patients remain in limbo

Credit: FRANCE 24 English    Duration: 02:00Published
This Day in History: New Orleanians Take to the Streets for Mardi Gras [Video]

This Day in History: New Orleanians Take to the Streets for Mardi Gras

This Day in History:, New Orleanians Take to the Streets for Mardi Gras. February 27, 1827. Groups of masked students danced in the streets, marking the beginnings of the city's Mardi Gras celebrations. The Mardi Gras celebration was brought to the region by French settlers towards the end of the 1600s. By the time students in New Orleans danced in the streets in costumes and masks. the celebration of Carnival had been popular in Mobile, AL, for more than 100 years. The New Orleans student celebrations were inspired by their Paris studies. Within five years, a French plantation owner had begun raising money to fund the celebration. The first fully organized Mardi Gras occurred in 1857

Credit: Wibbitz Top Stories    Duration: 00:50Published

Supreme Court of the United States Supreme Court of the United States Highest court of jurisdiction in the United States

US Supreme Court to hear Trump immunity claim [Video]

US Supreme Court to hear Trump immunity claim

Credit: FRANCE 24 English    Duration: 10:24Published

Supreme Court mulls whether 9-Judge bench can put Article 31 validity to test

Supreme Court on Wednesday witnessed an engrossing debate over the existing architecture of Article 31C, added to the Constitution in 1971 to shield legislations..
IndiaTimes

SC mulls whether 9-J bench can put Article 31 validity to test

Supreme Court on Wednesday witnessed an engrossing debate over the existing architecture of Article 31C, added to the Constitution in 1971 to shield legislations..
IndiaTimes

Supreme Court: Can't pass order on EVMs on suspicion of manipulation

On Wednesday, the Supreme Court indicated its reluctance to issue any directives solely based on suspicions of hacking and manipulation concerning electronic..
IndiaTimes

Related videos from verified sources

BREAKING: Alabama Supreme Court RESTRICTS IVF?! [Video]

BREAKING: Alabama Supreme Court RESTRICTS IVF?!

In a massive win for the pro-life movement, the Alabama Supreme Court has ruled that frozen embryos are children and those who destroy them may be held accountable for wrongful death. In the wake of..

Credit: RumblePublished
Alabama hospital pauses IVF treatments following ruling saying frozen embryos are children [Video]

Alabama hospital pauses IVF treatments following ruling saying frozen embryos are children

The US state of Alabama's Supreme Court recently ruled that frozen embryos can be considered children under state law.

Credit: euronews (in English)     Duration: 00:35Published